Keep in good health who come on, write books? Only

Keep in good health who come on, write books? Only 18% of genuine expert in 128 authors of best seller
Times reporter Wang ZhiSheng of the health


The books are pursued by consumer to keep in good health. CFP is pursued

Read briefing on:

Keeping in good health books, it is a large light spot of the market of books in recent years, the sales volume reaches up to a million easily, the demand is very vigorous. But on the other hand, the public, to keep in good health messy like criticize, up to summit even books expert.

The reporter takes sells the platform in the network health care books as a basis, has carried on the investigation one by one to the authors of salable the first 200 books. Found finally, the hospital expert or author who was studied universities and colleges of medicine only accounted for 18%!

In the face of the market that fish and dragons mix up together, someone says that will examine author's identity, someone says that sets up and publishes the threshold, also the personage thinks, the health books are different from the clinical textbook, so long as accord with the great medical principle, readers are benefited. If the answer is certainly, so " without solid foundation or training " Author but also it's time definite.

The really medical expert only accounts for 18%

The Times reporter of the health has chosen our country's biggest books sale website - -On the health-related list of best selling of network, carry on the census according to the health care books of the first 200 situations of selling well that the descending order of the sales volume arrange, finished by 128 authors together.

Through find to 128 the intersection of author and verification of identity these, have medical author of background only there are 9 in the intersection of the first, second and third and hospital among them, accounts for 7%! They are Hu Da one, ZhaoGuang Hong, to red man expert and the intersection of academy of sciences and west attending physician of garden hospital Zhi and cardiovascular Wang Cheng,etc., chief physician of centre, Li, Chinese medicine of China, that the public familiar with extremely.

Learn whom the universities and colleges work as in medicine and is 14, accounts for 10.9%, such as Wang Li, professor of academy of sciences of Wang Qi, Professor of Beijing University of Trad. Chinese Medicine, He Juan, associate professor Qu LiMin, Professor of Guangzhou Chinese Medicine University Fu JieYing, China's Chinese medicine,etc.. It only account for 18% the two too for.

"Two Chengdu is less than, this proportion is so really low as to my imagination has happened. " Traditional Chinese medicine learn popular science warm long Luis, General Board of branch, seem in China, the market of health care book, it should be " genuine " The expert's position, especially Chinese medicine expert, this is their line. But the realistic situation is, a lot " genuine " The expert is often busy with clinic or scientific research, it is unable to take the scientific education into account.

"Is not it really free? This is not all. If books publish, regard standard to promote the professional title one of as too keep in good health, I estimate keep in good health books can little than medical theses. "

Another outstanding reason is that " what it is available might not be written, the ones that can be written might not say " ,Experts that the clinic, health education such as big clear light, professor Hu Da one have a bumper harvest can be really too few.

On June 8, one claims to be already been engaged in the health care books and plan the books editor of more than 4 years, course of coming out of the stove in the online revealed secrets health care books of ends of the earth. He claims more than 90% of the health care books are not written by the expert!

"Because expert's ox very in the professional field, the thing which he wrote, ordinary people can not understand, and let experts write the book in person, the cost is very high, so, planning the editor begins to look for and write hands, work as the expert's marksman. "

24% of the authors " Without solid foundation or training "

" prolonged illness makes a doctor of a patient " , " old and well-known family of Chinese medicine " A books author passes through and uses to keep in good health" The title " . The investigation finds, in 128 authors, 19 people claimed old and well-known family of Chinese medicine, accounts for 14.8%.

But these " The old and well-known family of Chinese medicine " ,Often pass some " of medias People's meat search " And then, find these hopeless great numbers of people that hold the banner of old and well-known family of Chinese medicine and pay propagating are not the real Chinese medicine old and well-known family, the title is only a gag proclaimed oneself.

And claim to " become educated through independent study " , " prolonged illness makes a doctor of a patient " Author piece reach 31 persons,it is 24%!

The intersection of author and YueLing Ma of " the non- sick intelligence ", claim, work as nurse for less than 23 year, once weak and sickly to exactly like Lin Daiyu, through trying to find out one's own, cost firm yuans of lotion, take and give birth to the loach, has found the healthy road of leading to. She declares " 99% of the diseases can be cured through consolidating origin " .

Insulted and ate and gave birth to the loach according to Ma Yue " The bean vermicelli " Make a stupid mistake especially: Disease in Sichuan Province accuses of the data that the centre releases to reveal, only the first 5 months of this year, there are more than 100 Ma YueLing " bean vermicelli " Take, give birth to loach, initiate, suffer from diarrhoea, can't live in hospital seriously.

Author of " the attitude determines to be healthy " " It is good like water to have " ,It was once a mother that illness was burdened with, begun to study Chinese medicine at 50 years old to call.

The intersection of " the 13 lymphocytic to rank the malicious calisthenics type " and author Zhuang XingZhen, from Taiwan. Claimed to endure the illness to the fullest extent to torment from 20 years old, suffered from cervical cancer, breast cancer and large intestine cancer 40 years old ago, therefore has developed a set of calisthenics of dredging the lymphocytic system of whole body, because does this to hold while weighing the internal cancer cell, have already been controlled, and no longer worsen.

Many experts of medical circle think, the qualification that do not practise medicine, even medical background does not possess, write out how books make us letter health care.

But someone queries, Chinese medicine is experience discipline, prolonged illness makes the patient a good doctor. Whether now or in the past, everybody was without solid foundation or training that there were many Chinese medicine. What's more, health education and clinical medicine are totally different trades, can't take the standard of the textbook of clinical medicine to appraise the health care books. In fact, clinical medicine, nutrition, health control are two totally different trades, judge another trade with the standard of a trade, like a square tenon for a round mortice.

"Overly emphasizing even setting up the threshold must be written the health books by the clinical expert, other people can't write, this comes from one kind and discriminates against. " An expert insisting on anonymity says, " the key problem lies in, readers look, is it benefited? Go on the healthy way? If the answer is definite, then these authors ' without solid foundation or training ' should get definitely. "

It is variant to supervise the trick abroad

Not long ago, national General Administration of Press and Publication published and invited medical, science and technology, professional person in charge of publishing house of popular science, jointly publish the keeping in good health books " Feel pulse " . Through discussing, have opened " prescription " ,Including evaluating the outstanding healthy books, set up and publish the threshold to the publishing house and the books carry on the strict censorship etc. to keeping in good health.

Abroad, the books consumers of the health pursue the intensity and second only to the novels, amusement books too, but every country is not the same in supervision of the health books.

For example, in Britain, the medical organization will invite the authoritative medical expert before a copy of health books goes on the market, carry on the assessment to science and social benefit of author's identity and this selected title? of Xi the intersection of Kun and Bu lie prone the intersection of tip and pregnant of vinegar sole shoe last flee Xi of small jar coral cut Ping post Long The mist Bin beach shoots Zhyuan to the mist sister-in-law to receive Peng Luo Li Hui in gear The low border Luo that it is surnamed Jue in straitened circumstances ]?

Praised as by " Times " " The intersection of U.S.A. and anti-fake medical the first person " Stephen Barrett introduce whether last books, there are getting getting more confused more very too on the markets, 77 -year-old Stephen and Barrett of this year, " the country swindles the committee against the health " after establishing public interest organization 30 years ago ; Over the past 30 years, he collect, prove, reveal over 150 person false to keep in good health expert and of all kinds the intersection of health care and fraud and false the intersection of maintaining good health by scientific methods and book. Because his remarkable contribution, U.S.A. FDA has awarded to Stephen " the public serves and especially contributes the award " ,The false medical health books which he revealed, will be FDA crime by swindling definitely. Market of U.S.A.'s health books is afraid at present Stephen finds fault, before comparing, already the norm has been numerous.

It is obvious, the source sets up the threshold, it is not the only method, medical advisor checks on, publish the self-containment of the trade, the supervision of the media, purify and standardize the valid measure of the market of health books.

Keep in good health who come on, write books? Only 18% of genuine expert in 128 authors of best seller