The boy 3 years old seeks medical advice and was

The boy 3 years old seeks medical advice and was successively misdiagnosed and transferred from one hospital to another and was ignored, died of illness
The boy 3 years old is young and strong (assumed name) High fever is not returned, the hand, mouth, foot present bleb, erythema and blister respectively. It is little to reach Tianjin and three hospital of Beijing, misdiagnose successively, transfer from one hospital to another, the intersection of hospital and the intersection of person who pay attention to and situation after passing through many different places while being strong for parents to bring, it is small and strong to die of illness finally. Little strong parents help and fit the hospital to inform the intersection of Tianjin and the intersection of Ji and the intersection of county and the intersection of native place and the intersection of town and commune hospital, the intersection of Capital University of Medical Sciences and subsidiary BJ Children's Hospital, subsidiary Beijing of Capital University of Medical Sciences that go to the court.

Yesterday the reporter learnt, a intermediate court of market was according to the expert's conclusion, the town commune hospital of native place of Tianjin Ji county of final judgement compensated for more than 20,000 yuan, help and fit the hospital to compensate more than 170,000 yuan in subsidiary Beijing of Capital University of Medical Sciences.

-The plaintiff narrates

Seek medical advice and misdiagnose it for influenza once

25 -year-old Mr. Wang and 26 -year-old Ms. Pan now, is the ordinary peasants of the town of native place of Tianjin Ji county. In November of 2006, it has been left small strongly that this pair of couple grew. It is the only grandson in the family to be small and strong, considered as the apple of one's eye.

The afternoon of June 12, 2010 is small and strong had a fever suddenly, the mucous membrane of oral cavity presented bleb, the blush appears around bleb, the hand presents erythema, the foot presents blister. Wang dare, neglect by Mr. and Ms. Pan, bring light to get from the intersection of house and closer the intersection of Tianjin and the intersection of Ji and the intersection of county and the intersection of native place and the intersection of town and commune hospital going to a doctor while being strong immediately.

According to Mr. Wang and Ms. Pan, commune hospital connect to light to carry on detailed serious physical examination while being strong examine, have not done any regular auxiliary examination either, make diagnosis quickly, assert it is influenza smallly and strongly, it is injected and write a prescription to let small strongly. Go home, small strong lasting hyperpyrexia still, husband and wife bring light to come to the town commune hospital of native place while being better again, this time, the commune hospital opens some oral medicines to give smallly and strongly again, and answer and claim it will be " better in a few days " .

Seek medical advice overstaffedly and transfer from one hospital to another by oneself twice

Will it be will it be before dawn June 14 2010, high fever and the spirit is listless gradually still, family lead him to rush for Beijing immediately, go to BJ Children's Hospital to go to a doctor. Diagnosing as the seriously ill disease of mouths of brothers of children's hospital.

It is small and strong to reach the serious disease stage, it is infectious disease, can't go to a doctor in the children's hospital, propose turning into the hospital treatment of infectious hospital. At that time, the children's hospital was overstaffed, if it will be time more consuming to get in touch to transfer from one hospital to another from the hospital, it takes 1 days. Little strong parents are afraid of delaying treating, demand to transfer from one hospital to another by oneself and and call a taxi to go to Beijing to help and fit the hospital immediately.

After Mr. Wang and Ms. Pan demand to transfer from one hospital to another by oneself, the children's hospital has not informed them about the difference of changing the place of examination by changing the place of examination and relative of medical organizations, only let them lead by oneself smallly and strongly to transfer from one hospital to another after signing. This and small to help Ann hospital to be paid attention to concerning certainly while being better.

Late that relatives kneel and ask that seek medical advice three times

Will it be will it be will it be over 3 o'clock before dawn June 14 2010, it is little to get to and help setting up the emergency call of the hospital while being better for them to bring. They show the relevant case history of the children's hospital to connect and examine a doctor. But the hospital has not offered the attention to little strong condition, the little strong infusion that only give, let them take small strongly and go home.

For the trust to hospital and doctor, little and strong family will take youngly and strongly home. However, it is small and strong after going home the condition is aggravated continuously instead.

At over 3 o'clock on the the afternoon of June 14, 2010, whole family return to and help fitting the hospital from Tianjin again. This time, ones that help and fit the hospital meet and examine a doctor in order to open oral administration and infusion medicine youngly and strongly, small to accept nearly 2 infusion of hours again while being strong, later, doctor let family bring little to come back home while being better also. Whole family return to Tianjin again.

At over 10 o'clock a.m. on June 15, 2010, on condition that become more serious continuously in little strong condition, whole family help fitting the hospital from Tianjin for third time. It is small and strong accepts after the infusion again, doctor and nurse require them to go home for the third time.

Only encouraging the introduction according to plaintiff lawyer Fang Pan, at that time, the child's grandmother knelt in the hospital hall, crying and shouting should look for a president, look for a doctor, ask the hospital to rescue children. In this case, help Ann hospital to agree to leave the view to the little strong emergency call at last, but until the same day 7 evening o'clock more than,help Ann hospital not to be had income institutes strongs light treated. However, it has been small and strong and already quite seriously ill at that time, in the death at 59 past 11 on June 16 finally.

Do not indict the hospital responsibly to delay repeatedly

Small strong death make the intersection of whole family and grief already, they think little strong condition to find in time, and make great efforts to go to each hospital to go to a doctor constantly. Small and strong death is complete because those irresponsible hospitals delay causing repeatedly. They decide to be sued and demanded the statement.

Little and strong family do not think the town commune hospital of native place has implemented serious and careful physical examination and relevant auxiliary examination to the infant, under paying the situation of great attention to the mouths of brothers in the whole country, diagnose rashly, treat carelessly, have not tried the corresponding attention obligation and told the obligation; BJ Children's Hospital is in a situation that infant relatives demand to transfer from one hospital to another by oneself, have not offered the difference of telling the medical organization changes the place of examination and relatives change the place of examination by oneself fully in detail, have not tried overall telling the obligation; Help and fit the case history material formed toward BJ Children's Hospital of hospital to turn a blind eye to, have not tried the corresponding attention obligation to the infant, has not for sufficient attention as to disease that the infant suffers frommed, in the important period for development of infant's condition, have not left view and income institute's treatment in time.

Little and strong family require three hospitals to compensate more than 260,000 yuan of economic losses, spirit damages and conciliates 200,000 yuan of gold.

-The hospital explains

There is no fault limitedly at the level of commune hospital of garrison post of native place

And the unwilling compensation of commune hospital of garrison post of native place points out, influenza and a disease of brothers are similar, as the medical organization at the basic level, the level is limited, so it is small and strong to diagnose it is influenza there is not fault.

Commune hospital say until situation confirm brothers mouth disease according to enough at that time, it is influenza that they think it young and strong. Though disease high to take place season for the intersection of brothers and mouth at that time, infant's clinical manifestation can't be made a definite diagnosis of. They have already adviced little strong parents and observed, paid attention to treating at any time, because little strong parents have not noticed, so has delayed the small strong treatment.

BJ Children's Hospital does not undertake the responsibility from the institute by oneself

The children's hospital says, small and strong after being diagnosed as brothers' disease fond of salty food, the doctor opens medicines, and fill in the mouths of brothers and report the card and infectious disease document of transferring from one hospital to another and plan to ask the expert of infectious hospital to hold a consultation, transfer to the infectious hospital. Little strong parents consider waiting time is relatively long, demand to transfer from one hospital to another to the infectious hospital by oneself. The our academy has already told parents the condition may have changed to transfer from one hospital to another in the course, but relatives still insist on changing over to and helping fitting the hospital.

Children's medicine? Drink and hold in the mouth 's page of decayed tooth of low Huan's kneecap sedan-chair of 's health pen Knock the bag in swollen pregnant happy Qu sea iridium Page is joined kindly in the adze. bungle writing brush wave trade the intersection of tool instrument and H Wei lie quail to be towering all?

Helps and fits the record of course of disease of the hospital and does not promise to pay compensation in detail in Beijing

At the time of the hospital treatment, there is not seriously ill disease of mouths of brothers that behave to help and fit the hospital and claim, it is small and strong, it is not enough to accept in hospital or leave the view standard. BJ Children's Hospital can let its parents sign and leave the institute, proves too infant's condition was relatively steady at that time.

Help, fit hospital, say doctor let light to leave hospital, bring down a fever while being better too and lightly while being strong each time and the condition is steady. It is and small strong to leave for view, in hospital when,it develop conditions strongs little too they, assign the critically ill, seriously ill notice to little strong parents, and the little and strong death is due to development of one's own disease. Help and fit the hospital to point out, it is not detailed to the record of course of disease at next day 06 past 7 that in hospital 06 past 23 on June 15, 2010 in the case history, so would like to compensate according to 20% of the proportions.

-Court's judgement

Point out many times the hospital is not responsible for

The bright straight judicial expertise centre of Beijing provided " judicial testimonial " on June 12, 2011. The testimonial is asserted, the town commune hospital of native place has medical fault, but have no causality with the little strong death; The children's hospital does not have medical fault; Have medical fault to fit the hospital to help, causality exists with the little strong death, propose it is 25% that the medical fault participates in degree, it is 20%-40% to compensate for and consult the range.

As to the intersection of native place and the intersection of town and commune hospital, court point out, small to appear the intersection of brothers and clinical symptom, mouth of disease already go to a doctor, while being strong, the town commune hospital of native place still diagnoses as simply " Influenza, upper airway infection " . Even if treat condition to be limited, should on take place the intersection of brothers and possibility, mouth of disease and change the place of examination, tell to the little strong party to of higher level importance of hospital in time. The court asserts, there should be slight, indirect causality between town commune hospital and little and strong death consequence of native place, should bear 5% of the civil liability.

As to the children's hospital, the court asserts, the hospital diagnoses as " the mouths of brothers are ill " It is correct, it accords with the norm too to the infectious hospital treatment to let it transfer from one hospital to another after little strong relatives sign and agree.

For helping fitting the hospital, the court points out some fault and irresponsible behavior more. First of all, court propose, help, fit in the case history of hospital quoting light strong at the time of going to a doctor in the children's hospital the intersection of blood and inspection only, record little strong blood pressure, image study the intersection of inspection and result, verify, help Ann hospital to light to go on these check while being better. Help, fit hospital under not understanding little strong stating of medical history already, to small to carry on biochemistry while being strong and blood pressure, image learn check measure allow light to leave institute while being better promptly, the medical fault exists.

In addition court point out in small to return to, help, fit hospital and appear hyperpyrexia and have easy to shy display, still for the second time while being strong, help Ann yet light to leave view while being strong hospital have, advise light strong one party from risk and notes to the ill of institute either, violate heavy disease and brothers' port disease and treat fault which pays attention to the obligation such as the norm again.

Finally, the court points out, the condition is developed urgently and suddenly at the time of small strong the third visit, this and help fitting the hospital and pay attention to the voluntary disappearance, leading to the fact the condition has not been controlled in time to store in relatedly. " it is small and strong after being admitted to hospital, helping Ann hospital makes the critically ill notice right away, and tell ' the infant may die at any time ' " . Court point out, make the rounds of the wards 7 point 06 June 16 such as late arrival by stages in will it be will it be 06 past 23 June 15 2010, doctor does not make the rounds of the wards to record, explain and help fitting the hospital and can not observe tightly the infant's condition, the fault exists. Though little strong condition is critical and fast growing, mainly his one's own disease causes the death, but help Ann hospital to lack enough attention obligations while to infant's outpatient service, accelerate little strong progress of disease to a certain extent, make light to lose obtain easy chance to treat and cure result while being strong, also there is less important causality with the small and strong and final death consequence, should bear 35% of the civil liability.

Court adjudiacate in the first instance native place town commune hospital compensate for 20,000 over, help, set up the hospital, compensate more than 170,000 yuan for finally.

Plaintiff lawyer Pan encourage, say, little better household are thought to compensate for too low, but because go to court for a long time only, the whole family's spirit has already almost collapsed, so they think the court has already asserted that help fitting the great responsibility of the hospital, so has not lodged a appeal. (Sun SiYa)


The boy 3 years old seeks medical advice and was successively misdiagnosed and transferred from one hospital to another and was ignored, died of illness